TD Direct Investing Review 2022
TD Direct Investing Review Summary:
- Trading Fees and Pricing
- Account Options
- ETF Trading Fees
- Customer Service
- Platform Options
- Overall Banking Convenience
TD Direct Investing Review Summary:
For those already customers of Toronto-Dominion bank, TD Direct will be a convenient place to do all of your financial transactions, from banking to trading. In our TD Direct Investing review, we’ll see how it stacks up against other online brokers to show you which one might be the best fit for your particular needs.
As with all big banks, the fees at TD Direct Investing are higher than other non-bank online brokers, with ETF and stock trades, for example, costing a whopping $9.99 per transaction. Other fees, like the $25 per quarter maintenance fee for accounts holding less than $15,000, make this a less attractive option for those who want a basic DIY service without the high fees.
For Canadian investors who don’t already bank with TD Bank, better, more user-friendly platforms with the same full range of account options can be enjoyed at a much lower price. Check out more about our most recommended Canadian online broker Qtrade.
- One of Canada’s most trusted financial companies
- Easy and convenient if you already bank with TD
- Modern, easy to use platform
- Good amount of account options to choose from
- Higher trading fees, ETFs in particular
- Very high account fees unless you maintain a $15K balance
TD Direct Investing is not rated as one of the best Canadian brokerages: Fees are high and there’s no active promotion.View Alternative, Better Rated Canadian Brokers
The TD Direct Investing online discount brokerage is amongst the most popular of Canada’s online discount brokerages. TD has consistently been on the forefront over the last decade as investors have moved away from expensive “full service brokers”, to the much cheaper discount broker model that we see today.
As one of Canada’s largest companies and a strong global competitor, it is no surprise that TD’s online trading platforms are amongst the most popular in Canada. Find out why in our in-depth TD Direct Investing review and learn more about their trading fees, accounts, and the different broker platforms that exist under the broader TD umbrella.
TD Direct Investing’s Trading Fees and Prices
When discussing TD Direct Investing’s Trading and account fees, it’s important to consider that TD (and their major competitors at BMO, Scotia, CIBC, and RBC) are not known for trying to be the lowest-cost providers of banking and investing services in Canada. Instead, they seek to provide ultra-safe products, and user-friendly customer experiences, at a competitive price model.
TD Direct Investing certainly accomplishes that goal. They provide elite-level usability and user options, for a similar price point as their competitors.
That being said, there are a number of different fees you’ll encounter if investing with TD Direct Investing, and they vary depending on the particular platform you are using.
Now we’ll have a look at the options under the TD umbrella and the fees that come with each, as well as look at how those fees compare to other trading platforms.
|TD WebBroker and TD Mobile Investing App||Advanced Dashboard for Active Traders||Questrade||Qtrade||CI Direct Investing (Virtual Brokers)|
|Maintenance Fee||$25 per quarter/$100 per year if your portfolio is less than $15,000 or certain conditions are met under the TD Household Program (ie. your household’s combined assets are above $15,000, or at least one member of your household sets up a $100+ monthly automatic contribution through the Systematic Investment Plan (SIP)).||Same as TD WebBroker and TD Mobile Investing. However, active traders are more likely to meet the set criteria and avoid paying a maintenance fee.||$0||$25 per quarter if your unless certain conditions are met (ie. balance is at least $25,000, or make a certain number or commissionable trades)||$24.95 per quarter charged as an administrative fee unless certain conditions are met (ie. balance is at least $25,000, one trade is completed per quarter having at least a $1.99 commission)|
|Stock Trading Fees and Commissions||$9.99 per trade||$7.00 per trade||As low as $0.01 to trade stocks||$8.75 for regular accounts, $6.95 for active investors||As low as $0.01 per share, $1.99 minimum, and $7.99 maximum per trade. $3.99 flat fee for active traders|
|ETF Trading Fees and Commissions||$9.99 per trade||$7.00 per trade||As low as $0 to purchase, $0.01 to sell||$0 for select ETF trades, $8.75 for all others for regular accounts, $6.95 for active investors||$0 to buy, $0.01 to sell, $1.99 minimum, and $7.99 maximum per trade.|
|ECN Fees||$0||$0||Usually $0, or a low fee with certain assets||$0||$0|
|Options Trading||$9.99 per trade + $1.25 per contract||$7.00 per trade + $1.25 contract fee||$9.95 per trade + $1 per contract||$8.75 per trade + $1.25 per contract for regular accounts, $6.75 per trade + $1.25 for active investors||$7.99 per trade + $1.25 per contract, $3.99 per trade + $1.25 for active investors|
By looking at the chart, it’s easy to see that by no means is by no means the least expensive option. Low fees and commissions are key to maximizing your investment, but TD Direct Investing’s high costs simply do not make it competitive in our comparison.
TD Direct Investing Platform Comparison
TD Canada Investing has three separate platforms, which can be a bit confusing, especially since one of their platforms, thinkorswim, is not available in Canada.
Below is a chart summarizing the highlights of each platform.
Investors and traders
Active U.S options trading
Minimum deposit and account balance
North American stocks and options trading
Advanced order types: stop, stop limit, trailing stops (by price and %), trailing stop limit
Streaming market data
Daily, weekly, and special reports
Financial statements, earnings estimates, ratio analysis and analyst ratings
400+ technical studies and 20 drawings, including eight Fibonacci tools
TD Direct Investing Account Types: TFSA, RRSP, Non-Registered
As a top-end online broker, TD Direct Investing offers all of the usual accounts including:
- Non-registered accounts (both CAD and USD)
- Margin Accounts
- RRSP (both CAD and USD)
The bottom line is that while you might pay more in commissions to use TD Direct Investing, you’re going to absolutely have access to all of the accounts that you could ask for as a Canadian Investor.
TD Direct Investing Platform and Tools
TD Direct Investing offers three different platforms, all offering a variety of investment tools. In this section of our TD Direct Investing Review we will dive into each one to check out what makes it unique.
WebBroker is the web-based platform used by most TD Direct Investing customers, as it’s easy to use. It allows for customers to personalize their homepage with useful at-a-glance information and training videos, and even interactive master classes.
WebBroker also provides access to analytical tools, market data, and reports to help users make the most of their investment opportunities.
Designed for on-the-go investors, the TD app allows users to easily execute orders, access up-to-date news and reports and monitor portfolio performance all from their mobile device. The app is 100% integrated with the WebBroker, offering users flexibility.
Active traders will have access to the Advanced Dashboard, which allows users to view real-time streaming data, and use features such as customizable research tools and charts, as well as access to both Canadian and US markets.
TD Easy Trade (Formerly TD GoalAssist)
As so many investors continue to pour into DIY online investing, in 2021 TD introduced a really cool new platform that the MDJ Editorial Team got pretty excited about. (Now if only those fees would come down!)
The TD app is known as TD Easy Trade and the idea is to help DIY index investors through the use of TD’s in-house ETF portfolios. The TD “one-click” portfolios (you can see how they compare to the rest of Canada’s all-in-one ETFs) are available through the app commission-free.
On top of offering free TD ETFs, TD Easy Trade doesn’t charge you for the first 50 stock trades per year. You won’t pay account maintenance fees either.
Paul Clark, the President of TD Direct Investing introduced the product by stating:
“We know investing can be intimidating and many Canadians may simply put off getting started as a result. We believe you shouldn’t need a lot of money or expertise to start building your investing journey, which is why we created TD GoalAssist. This new mobile-only investing service is straightforward, uses plain language and is grounded in what our clients have told us they’re looking for – goal planning, education and low cost.”
Clark then went on to add:
“We know a lot has changed in our lives this year as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. From an investing perspective, we’ve seen a significant increase in demand for online investing and more people trying investing on their own. TD GoalAssist could not come at a better time as Canadians are looking for an easy and affordable way to invest.”
TD Easy Trade is a great place for beginners to learn about investing, but in our opinion, once you learn the ropes, there are better options out there.
First, you won’t want to be limited to only TD ETFs as your portfolio grows. You also won’t want to start paying $9.99 for stock trades if you make more than 50 per year when you can get them for free elsewhere.
Since TD Easy Trade launched its app, it has received mixed reviews, with users commenting on negative aspects such as customer service issues, updates that caused major login complications, and trading limitations. Some of the positive comments were related to its ease of use as well as the fact that it offers so many educational resources to really help new investors learn about investing. Users also seem to appreciate the goal tracking function to help investors track their progress, which can be really motivating for newer investors.
Over time, we expect the app’s functionality to improve, but only time will tell. We’ll keep you updated here with any developments.
October 2021 Update – TD Direct Investing Improves Customer Service and Platform
After experiencing massive growth in 2020 and 2021, many of Canada’s discount brokerages sought to find solutions to their customer service delays.
TD has been at the front of the pack (as one would expect from a well-funded full service big bank brokerage). In a recent article, TD Direct Investing Raymond Chun revealed that TD’s discount brokerage business had added 35% more licensed investors since March of 2020.
Additionally, they have majorly upgraded their overall platform so that it can perform across various devices. Chun highlighted this work saying, “We’re at a place now where the majority of our customer transactions are being done through a mobile device… right from account opening to actual trades.”
TD’s focus on arming online DIY investors with a full toolbox of options resulted in the brokerage also offering online GIC purchases for the first time.
TD Direct Investing FAQ
Who Is TD Direct Investing Discount Broker Best for?
For current TD Bank customers, given their brokerage’s trustworthy track record in terms of customer service and security, as well as the fact that they provide a variety of products and educational tools, TD Direct could be a good option for those who value convenience.
As always, we want to look at the potential cons as well, and in our TD Direct Investing Review, we see that they are by far one of the more expensive options. With a $9.99 trading fee and $25 quarterly fee, you might expect more bells and whistles. While there are ways to lower those costs, unfortunately, the products and service just don’t justify the high price tag.
Brokers like Qtrade and Questrade definitely come out ahead when it comes to DIY investing and saving you money. Read our Qtrade review or our Questrade review for more information about why we think they are still cut above TD Direct Investing.